MongoDB Atlas vs DigitalOcean Managed MongoDB: The Developer's Guide

MongoDB has become a go-to choice for modern applications, and for good reason. Its flexible document model, powerful query language, and excellent developer experience make it ideal for everything from simple web apps to complex data platforms.

But when it comes to hosting MongoDB in production, you face a decision: do you go with MongoDB's own Atlas service, or opt for a third-party managed offering like DigitalOcean's managed MongoDB?

This guide provides a practical comparison to help developers and architects make an informed choice. We'll cover real pricing (in GBP), feature differences, and specific scenarios where each option makes sense.

Atlas tier breakdown (correcting common misconceptions)

Before comparing providers, let's clear up a common source of confusion about MongoDB Atlas pricing.

There is no "M1" tier. Despite what some outdated articles and AI-generated content might suggest, MongoDB Atlas doesn't offer an M1 tier. The actual tier structure is:

Tier	RAM	Storage	CPU	Price (GBP)	Best for
M0	512MB	512MB	Shared	Free	Learning, prototyping
M2	Shared	2GB	Shared	£7/month	Small apps, dev/test
M5	Shared	5GB	Shared	£20/month	Small production apps
M10	2GB	10GB	Dedicated	£45/month	Production workloads
M20	4GB	20GB	Dedicated	£95/month	Growing production

The M0 free tier is genuinely useful for development and learning. It's one of Atlas's strongest competitive advantages. However, the jump from M5 (shared, £20/month) to M10 (dedicated, £45/month) is significant, and M10 is realistically the minimum tier for any production workload that needs reliable performance.

What about vector search?

A notable update from 2024: MongoDB Atlas now offers vector search capabilities on all tiers, including the free M0. Previously, vector search required dedicated (M10+) clusters. This makes Atlas a more compelling option for AI and machine learning experimentation without upfront costs.

DigitalOcean MongoDB pricing

DigitalOcean takes a straightforward approach to managed MongoDB pricing:

Configuration	RAM	Storage	CPU	High availability	Price (GBP)
Single node	1GB	15GB	1 vCPU	No	£12/month
Single node	2GB	30GB	1 vCPU	No	£24/month
HA cluster	4GB	60GB	2 vCPU	Yes	£47/month
HA cluster	8GB	120GB	2 vCPU	Yes	£95/month

As of November 2024, DigitalOcean also introduced independent storage scaling, meaning you can increase storage without upgrading the entire cluster. Maximum storage now reaches 16TB for larger deployments.

Direct comparison: 2GB RAM production workload

Let's compare like-for-like for a typical small production workload requiring 2GB RAM:

Provider	Tier	RAM	Storage	Monthly cost	CPU type
MongoDB Atlas	M10	2GB	10GB	£45	Dedicated
DigitalOcean	Single node	2GB	30GB	£24	1 vCPU dedicated

DigitalOcean is 47% cheaper (£24 vs £45) while offering 3x more storage (30GB vs 10GB).

For a production workload with high availability requirements:

Provider	Configuration	RAM	Storage	Monthly cost
MongoDB Atlas	M10	2GB	10GB	£45
DigitalOcean	HA cluster	4GB	60GB	£47

At nearly the same price point, DigitalOcean's HA cluster offers double the RAM and 6x the storage. The trade-off is that Atlas includes more advanced features (covered below).

Feature comparison

Price isn't everything. Here's how the two platforms compare on features that matter for production deployments:

Feature	MongoDB Atlas	DigitalOcean MongoDB
Vector search	Yes (all tiers, 2024)	Yes (MongoDB 7.0)
Automated backups	Continuous (paid tiers)	Daily (7-day retention)
Point-in-time recovery	Yes (M10+)	Yes (included)
Monitoring and alerts	Atlas UI + comprehensive alerts	DO dashboard + alerts
Auto-scaling	Yes	Manual (storage scales independently)
Global distribution	Multi-region clusters	Single region only
Serverless option	Atlas Serverless available	Not available
Data API	Yes (HTTP endpoints)	Via connection string only
Charts and visualisation	Atlas Charts included	Third-party only
Advanced security	Encryption, LDAP, audit logs	Encryption, VPC
Maximum storage	Up to 4TB	Up to 16TB

Where Atlas wins

Atlas shines in several areas:

• Global distribution: If you need multi-region clusters with automatic failover across continents, only Atlas offers this as a managed service.
• Serverless: Atlas Serverless is ideal for unpredictable workloads where you want to pay per operation rather than per hour.
• Atlas Charts: Built-in visualisation tool for creating dashboards directly from your data.
• Data API: HTTP endpoints for accessing data without a MongoDB driver, useful for edge functions and serverless environments.
• Vector search maturity: While both support vector search, Atlas's implementation is more optimised and better documented.

Where DigitalOcean wins

DigitalOcean has advantages too:

• Price-performance ratio: 47% cheaper for equivalent specs with more generous storage.
• UK data residency: London datacentre available, important for UK businesses with data residency requirements.
• Ecosystem integration: If you're already using DigitalOcean for Kubernetes, App Platform, or Spaces, everything lives in one dashboard with private networking between services.
• Storage capacity: Up to 16TB vs Atlas's 4TB maximum.
• Simplicity: Fewer options means faster setup and less decision fatigue.

When to choose each option

Based on the comparison, here are clear recommendations for different scenarios:

Choose MongoDB Atlas M0/M2 if:

• You're learning MongoDB or building a prototype (the free M0 tier is unbeatable)
• You have a very small application with minimal database needs
• You want to experiment with vector search without cost (available on free tier)
• Your monthly budget is under £10

Cost: Free (M0) or £7/month (M2)

Choose MongoDB Atlas M10+ if:

• You need global multi-region distribution (only Atlas offers this)
• You require Atlas-specific features like Serverless, Charts, or Data API
• You want automated auto-scaling without manual intervention
• You have specific compliance requirements that Atlas certifications address
• Budget is £45+/month and features matter more than cost

Cost: £45/month (M10), £95/month (M20)

Choose DigitalOcean MongoDB if:

• Cost optimisation is a priority (47% cheaper than Atlas M10)
• You need UK data residency (London datacentre)
• You're already using DigitalOcean for other infrastructure (DOKS, PostgreSQL, Spaces)
• You need simple, predictable pricing without complex tier decisions
• Standard MongoDB features are sufficient (no exotic Atlas features required)
• Budget is £12-95/month

Cost: £24/month (2GB single), £47/month (4GB HA)

The hybrid strategy: best of both worlds

Here's a strategy we've found works well for teams balancing cost and capability:

Development and staging: MongoDB Atlas M0 (Free)

Use Atlas's free tier for all development and staging environments. It's sufficient for testing, provides the full Atlas experience for developers, and costs nothing.

Production: DigitalOcean MongoDB (£24/month)

Run production workloads on DigitalOcean for significant cost savings. For a 2GB production cluster, you save £21/month compared to Atlas M10.

This approach gives you:

• Zero cost for development environments
• 47% savings on production infrastructure
• Developers familiar with both platforms (useful for projects that genuinely need Atlas features)

Migration between platforms

Concerned about lock-in? Migration between Atlas and DigitalOcean is straightforward:

1. Export data from source (mongodump)
2. Provision target managed MongoDB
3. Import data (mongorestore)
4. Update connection strings in your application
5. Test thoroughly before cutover

Typical downtime: 15-60 minutes depending on data size. Both platforms support free data export, and DigitalOcean doesn't charge for inbound data transfer.

Three-year total cost of ownership

For teams planning longer-term, here's how costs compare over three years for a 2GB RAM equivalent deployment:

Provider/Tier	Monthly	Annual	3-year total	Notes
Atlas M0	Free	Free	Free	512MB only, development use
Atlas M2	£7	£84	£252	2GB storage, shared CPU
Atlas M10	£45	£540	£1,620	2GB RAM, dedicated
DO 2GB Single	£24	£288	£864	2GB RAM, 30GB storage
DO 4GB HA	£47	£564	£1,692	4GB RAM with HA

Choosing DigitalOcean over Atlas M10 saves £756 over three years for equivalent production hosting, while providing triple the storage.

Conclusion

Both MongoDB Atlas and DigitalOcean managed MongoDB are solid choices, but they serve different needs:

MongoDB Atlas is the right choice when you need:

• Free development environments (unmatched M0 tier)
• Global distribution capabilities
• Atlas-specific features (Charts, Serverless, Data API)
• Maximum flexibility and advanced features

DigitalOcean MongoDB is the right choice when you need:

• Cost-effective production hosting (47% cheaper)
• UK data residency
• Simple, predictable pricing
• Integration with existing DigitalOcean infrastructure

For many teams, the hybrid approach works best: Atlas M0 for development (free), DigitalOcean for production (47% savings). This combination delivers the best of both platforms while optimising costs.

The "M1 tier" doesn't exist, and outdated information suggesting otherwise should be disregarded. Make your decision based on current pricing and your specific requirements.

---

Ready to try DigitalOcean?

If you've decided DigitalOcean is the right fit for your MongoDB hosting, you can sign up using our referral link to receive $200 in free credits over 60 days. That's enough to run a 2GB MongoDB cluster for over 8 months - plenty of time to validate whether the platform meets your needs.

Disclosure: This is a referral link. If you sign up and spend $25, we receive a small credit. This doesn't influence our analysis - we recommend the best tool for each situation regardless of referral programmes.

---

Planning a MongoDB deployment? Whether you're starting fresh or evaluating a migration from your current provider, we can help you choose the right infrastructure for your workload and budget. Get in touch to discuss your requirements.